This review contains affiliate links, which earn me a small commission when you click and purchase, at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my small business and allowing me to continue providing you a reliable resource for clean book ratings.
After going through some heart-wrenching life challenges, Laurel hears about the possibility of working at the McMurdo research base in Antarctica. McMurdo doesn’t need her scientific expertise, which is in fungi, so she just takes a leave from her professorship at a university and becomes a steward, serving food and doing cleanup at the station.
She’d hoped possibly to leave (some of) the pain behind, but then her ex-husband inexplicably shows up at the base months after her arrival. Laurel had become fascinated by the “Arc,” a strange curve of light that had appeared over the ice, and scientists were trying to figure out what it was. And Eli comes to study it with a team of physicists.
After watching it for months and ruminating on her life and losses, Laurel has a crazy idea. She pieces together what she hears about the Arc and the physics theories that Eli had specialized in, adds in a gut feeling, and makes a proposal to Eli.
Perhaps… just perhaps, they could turn back time and fix what had broken in their lives. Reclaim the loss.
I can’t say much more about the novel’s plot because it goes in such unexpected directions, and the discovery of those directions is an important and exciting part of reading. I’ll say it’s definitely science fiction, based on some real theories. More than half of the book is fantastical, but in the best ways. The story is fascinating and gripping, and I just had to see what happened. So many intriguing ideas, and such imagination for Benjamin to craft them.
At its core, though, as all great literature is, whether it’s out-there science fiction or fantasy or historical fiction, Under Story is very much about humanity: a couple’s love, their bond, and how deep grief affects them individually and together. The book also dives into ecology, botany, and the soul of Earth and the beings on it: plants, humans, animals.
Benjamin writes in her acknowledgements, “The research I did for this book altered my perspective on nonhuman life. This led me to pivot in ways I never anticipated; I stopped eating meat, for instance…. If any part of the novel moves you to fight for the protection of our world and all of its inhabitants—or for the importance of physical experience and connection in our increasingly virtual lives—nothing would mean more to me.” I admit I still am not at a point of choosing to go vegetarian or vegan, but I so appreciated the wonder I felt at this world and all that’s in it as I read various parts of Under Story.
I don’t often have high expectations for celebrity book club picks, but I read this one because I was rating it for content and then when I saw it had fairly low numbers of profanity and then read the description, I was intrigued. And the book just hooked me. It took me a week to read (it’s fairly long), but it was all excellent. One good sign was that I pondered on it after closing my Kindle every evening, and especially for a while when I finished. There was a lot to chew on! I recommend Under Story highly. It really would be a good choice for a book club.
Rated: Moderate. Profanity includes 2 uses of strong language, fewer than 10 instances of moderate profanity, about 5 uses of mild language, and about 30 instances of the name of Deity in vain. Sexual content includes four or five very brief scenes (a few sentences each) with a little erotic detail. There are other references to sex happening, though no details, and quick references to self-pleasuring. There are a few references to drug use (smoking or eating marijuana). TW: a child’s accidental death is a big part of the story.
Click here to purchase your copy of Under Story on Amazon.




