I am not sure if you are aware of this, but Never Eighteen is a work of fiction, and that does require the reader in some cases to accept things that are not necessarily as they would be in real life. Perhaps that is why Austin has the ability to touch those around him in the way he did — something you have difficulty believing in. I have been in school libraries for the past 17 years, and although it is sad to say, many students do have lives that are filled with strife-filled, sad, lonely and dark experiences — and these kids worlds are not in urban settings, but rather in middle-class America. Megan has woven a story around Austin (and in many ways his friend Kaylee) as they face some of these troubles and try to make them better. Isn’t that what we tell our children? Be kind to those around you? Help others? Do unto others as you would have done unto you?

As for the vivid sexual scenes and foul language, I respectfully disagree. Do they have sex? Yes. BUT it is in no ways as graphic as it is in the many of the books out there. It was portrayed quietly, calmly, lovingly and most importantly, NOT IN DETAIL. The reader, if tuned in, simply knew.

Megan Bostic’s book Never Eighteen touches on many troubling subjects in a kind, gentle and humane way — leaving those who have read it in a better place. It has been a favorite of my students for the majority of this year — boys and girls alike — and has made for great conversations. I, like them, feel better for having read it. Unfortunately, and respectfully, I think you missed the point. The loss is yours.

Rating of your review: DIRT.